IEACOR Where Science Meets Clarity

Example reports

What a paid assessment report covers

Five fictional organizations, shortened. Every finding below is made up to show the format.

Each report covers the areas that organization chose and gives each one a risk level and what we found. The full report also sets out the fixes in order and the rule or guidance each one answers. These organizations are fictional. They are not clients, and nothing here describes a real organization.

Fictional example 1

A 30-person biotech lab

Grant-funded, publishes in journals, uses AI for literature summaries and first drafts.

AreaRisk levelWhat we found
Checking AI outputHighAI-drafted summaries reach grant reports without a set check of their references.
Funder, journal and regulator rulesHighApplications are drafted with AI, and the funder's current AI rules haven't been reviewed.
Confidential dataModerateThe data rule doesn't cover contractors, who use a free chatbot.
Disclosure and authorshipModerateAI use is disclosed, but not the same way each time.

Fictional example 2

A 12-person weight-management clinic

A clinical practice that uses AI to draft patient letters and handouts.

AreaRisk levelWhat we found
Patient informationCriticalPatient details go into a free AI tool whose vendor has signed no business associate agreement.
Confidential dataHighThere is no written rule on what may go into AI tools.
Checking AI outputModerateAI-drafted handouts reach patients without a clinician's review.
AI tools in useModerateThree tools in use, one on a personal account, and no list.

Fictional example 3

An 80-person medical writing firm

Writes manuscripts and reports for pharmaceutical clients, with a written AI policy.

AreaRisk levelWhat we found
Contracts and ownershipModerateClient contracts don't cover AI use, or who owns AI-drafted sections.
Disclosure and authorshipLowA standard disclosure line is in place and used on every manuscript.

Fictional example 4

An 18-person regulatory consultancy

Prepares regulatory submissions for small drug developers.

AreaRisk levelWhat we found
Confidential dataHighClient documents have gone into a general chatbot on a personal account.
Funder, journal and regulator rulesModerateSome of the firm's AI use may fall under a regulator's draft guidance, and nobody has checked which.
Checking AI outputModerateDrafts are reviewed, but AI-supplied citations aren't checked.

Fictional example 5

A 40-person research foundation

A grant-funded nonprofit whose staff also serve on review panels.

AreaRisk levelWhat we found
Funder, journal and regulator rulesHighProposals under review were summarized with a chatbot.
Confidential dataModerateThe data rule leaves out material others share in confidence.
TrainingModerateOne team has had AI training; another hasn't.

Where the guidance comes from

Each finding in an IEACOR report is compared with published rules and guidance. In these examples, that guidance comes from:

  • National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
  • National Institutes of Health (NIH)
  • National Science Foundation (NSF)
  • U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
  • U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)
  • U.S. Copyright Office
  • International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE)

Named as sources only. IEACOR is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of these organizations.

Abbreviations on this page. AI: artificial intelligence · FDA: U.S. Food and Drug Administration · HHS: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services · ICMJE: International Committee of Medical Journal Editors · NIH: National Institutes of Health · NIST: National Institute of Standards and Technology · NSF: National Science Foundation · U.S.: United States · W3C: World Wide Web Consortium